强化嗓音训练对顽固性男声女调的疗效分析

Efficacy of intensive voice therapy for refractory puberphonia

高绫;王睿卿;陈伟峰;兰琳琳;邹嵩;庄佩耘

1:厦门大学附属中山医院嗓音科

2:厦门市嗓音医学重点实验室

3:赣南医科大学第一附属医院耳鼻咽喉-头颈外科

4:厦门大学医学院

摘要
目的 评估强化嗓音训练对顽固性男声女调的疗效。方法 纳入33例顽固性男声女调患者作为试验组和33例无发声障碍的健康男性作为对照组。所有患者均接受1个月的强化嗓音训练。使用Ling Waves分析系统,在训练前和训练后6个月评估患者的声学参数,包括基频(F_0)、F_0标准差、频率微扰(jitter)、振幅微扰(shimmer)、不规则性、气息声、总体严重度和声门噪声激励比;同时采用嗓音障碍指数(voice handicap index-30,VHI-30)对患者的主观感受进行评估。结果 与训练前相比较,训练后试验组F_0、F_0标准差、频率微扰、振幅微扰、气息声及总体严重度均显著降低,声门噪声激励比显著升高(均为P<0.017),VHI-30总分及功能、生理、心理各维度得分均显著下降(均为P<0.001)。训练前,试验组上述指标与对照组相比差异有统计学意义(均为P<0.017);训练后,两组间差异均无统计学意义(均为P>0.017)。结论 强化嗓音训练是治疗顽固性男声女调的有效方法,能够恢复患者正常音调,显著减轻其嗓音障碍的主观感受,避免不必要的手术。
关键词
男声女调;嗓音训练;功能性发声障碍
基金项目(Foundation):
国家自然科学基金项目(871155);; 2023年江西省卫生健康委员会科技计划项目(202310771)
作者
高绫;王睿卿;陈伟峰;兰琳琳;邹嵩;庄佩耘
参考文献

[1] ZIMMAN L.Transgender voices:insights on identity,embodiment,and the gender of the voice[J].Language and Linguistics Compass,2018,12(8):e12284.

[2] WU H X,LI Y,CHING B H H,et al.You are how you speak:the roles of vocal pitch and semantic cues in shaping social perceptions[J].Perception,2023,52(1):40-55.

[3] DAGLI M,SATI I,ACAR A,et al.Mutational falsetto:intervention outcomes in 45 patients[J].The Journal of Laryngology & Otology,2008,122(3):277-281.

[4] LIANG F Y,HUANG X M,CHEN L,et al.Voice therapy effect on mutational falsetto patients:a vocal aerodynamic study[J].Journal of Voice,2017,31(1):114.e1-114.e5.

[5] SALTURK Z,DOGANAY T,USTUN O,et al.Efficacy of low mandible maneuver on mutational falsetto[J].Folia Phoniatrica et Logopaedica,2021,73(5):442-448.

[6] DENIZOGLU I I,SAHIN M,BAYRAK S,et al.Efficacy of doctorvox voice therapy technique for mutational falsetto[J].Journal of Voice,2019,33(6):950.e1-950.e8.

[7] 张毅,魏春生,蒋家琪.言语训练在治疗男声女调中的应用[J].听力学及言语疾病杂志,2009,17(3):283-284.

[8] VUKOVIC B,CALASAN S.Puberphonia:from classic to modern approach[J].Biomedicinska Istra??ivanja,2021,12(1):90-98.

[9] van den BROEK E M J M,VOKES D E,DORMAN E B.Bilateral in-office injection laryngoplasty as an adjunctive treatment for recalcitrant puberphonia:a case report and review of the literature[J].Journal of Voice,2016,30(2):221-223.

[10] ZIWEI Y,ZHENG P,PIN D.Multiparameter voice assessment for voice disorder patients:a correlation analysis between objective and subjective parameters[J].Journal of Voice,2014,28(6):770-774.

[11] CHACKO S P,JOSHI A A,DAVE V.Acoustic analysis:an objective tool in evaluating patients with voice disorders[J].International Journal of Phonosurgery & Laryngology,2020,10(2):29-32.

[12] BROCKMANN-BAUSER M,BALANDAT B,BOHLENDER J E.Immediate lip trill effects on the standard diagnostic measures voice range profile,jitter,maximum phonation time,and dysphonia severity index[J].Journal of Voice,2020,34(6):874-883.

[13] URBANO M,BENSOUSSAN Y.Professional voice and muscle tension dysphonia:the art of the multi-disciplinary team[M].Perspectives in Performing Arts Medicine Practice II:Occupational Health,Public Health,Arts for Healing.Cham:Springer Nature Switzerland,2025:105-121.

[14] 徐文,李红艳,胡蓉,等.嗓音障碍指数量表中文版信度和效度评价[J].中华耳鼻咽喉头颈外科杂志,2008,43(9):670-675.

[15] VLATOSZEK B B,MARYN Y,GERRITS E,et al.A meta-analysis:acoustic measurement of roughness and breathiness[J].Journal of Speech,Language,and Hearing Research,2018,61(2):298-323.

[16] LIU H,HAO G,CHEN S,et al.Effectiveness and feasibility of telepractice on voice therapy for female teachers in elementary schools with self-reported voice disorders[J].Journal of Voice,2024,38(1):244.e1-244.e13.

[17] PATEL R R,PICKERING J,STEMPLE J,et al.A case report in changes in phonatory physiology following voice therapy:application of high-speed imaging[J].Journal of Voice,2012,26(6):734-741.

[18] SAVAREH S,MORADI N,YAZDI M J S,et al.Immediate effects of semi-occluded vocal tract exercises as a vocal warm-up in singers[J].Journal of Voice,2023,37(6):875-880.

[19] REMACLE M,MATAR N,VERDUYCKT I,et al.Relaxation thyroplasty for mutational falsetto treatment[J].Annals of Otology,Rhinology & Laryngology,2010,119(2):105-109.

[20] GARCIA-LOPEZ I,PENARROCHA J,GAVILAN J.Type III thyroplasty for the treatment of high-pitched voice disorder[J].Acta Otorrinolaringologica (English Edition),2010,61(4):318-320.

[21] 张雅丽,何晓光.Ⅲ型甲状软骨成形术治疗男声女调[J].听力学及言语疾病杂志,2009,17(4):385-386.