三个自适应模式的普通话噪声下语句识别阈测听工具的比较

Comparison of three computer-assisted adaptive Chinese Mandarin sentence in noise tests for recognition threshold assessment

隋锦明;宋依航;仇心悦;郗昕

1:山东医药大学特殊教育与康复学院

2:北京联合大学特殊教育学院

3:北京联合大学发展性障碍教育研究中心

4:中国人民解放军总医院第六医学中心耳鼻咽喉头颈外科医学部

摘要
目的 比较三款汉语普通话噪声下语句识别阈测听材料在正常听力年轻女性中的正常参考值及变异度,为临床选择快捷准确的测试工具提供参考。方法 选取36例听力正常女大学生,年龄19.8±0.6岁,受试耳各频率听阈均小于15 dB HL,分别使用三款自适应模式的噪声下语句测听材料,即普通话版噪声下听力测试(Mandarin hearing in noise test, MHINT)、普通话嘈杂噪声下BKB语句(Mandarin Bench-Koval-Bamford sentence in babble noise, MBKB-IBN)、中文普通话版矩阵式语句(Chinese Mandarin matrix sentence, CMNmatrix),进行信噪比识别阈测试。施测方案采用拉丁方设计,三款工具的测试顺序以及每款软件中施测的三张测试表顺序在36例被试中均衡排布。结果 MHINT、MBKB-IBN和CMNmatrix的信噪比识别阈依次为-2.79±0.78、-5.21±0.52、-8.53±0.35 dB SNR。单因素重复测量方差分析显示,MHINT的言语识别阈显著高于MBKB-IBN(P<0.001)和CMNmatrix(P<0.001), MBKB-IBN言语识别阈显著高于CMNmatrix(P<0.001),提示三款材料并非等难度工具,其标准差也呈逐步递减趋势。结论 在正常听力年轻女性中,MHINT、MBKB-IBN、CMNmatrix三种噪声下语句测试材料的信噪比识别阈及标准差均依次降低,CMNmatrix的测试难度较低且离散程度更小,能较准确且稳定地得出受试者的言语识别阈值;MBKB-IBN居中,而MHINT的测试难度及离散程度都较高。该结果可作为临床选择测试工具的参考依据之一。
关键词
噪声下言语测听;言语识别阈;嘈杂语噪声;信噪比
基金项目(Foundation):
作者
隋锦明;宋依航;仇心悦;郗昕
参考文献

[1] NILSSON M,SOLI S D,SULLIVAN J A.Development of the hearing in noise test for the measurement of speech reception thresholds in quiet and in noise[J].Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,1994,95(2):1085-1099.

[2] KOLLMEIER B,WARZYBOK A,HOCHMUTH S,et al.The multilingual matrix test:principles,applications,and comparison across languages:a review[J].International Journal of Audiology,2015,54(Suppl 2):3-16.

[3] BENCH J,KOWAL A,BAMFORD J.The BKB (Bamford-Kowal-Bench) sentence lists for partially-hearing children[J].British Journal of Audiology,1979,13(3):108-112.

[4] 郗昕,陈艾婷,李佳楠,等.嘈杂语噪声下普通话儿童语句测听表的标准化[J].听力学及言语疾病杂志,2009,17(4):318-322.

[5] 郑宇扬,杨宇,胡旭君.噪声下普通话数字串听力筛查测试材料的开发与验证[J].听力学及言语疾病杂志,2023,31(4):318-323.

[6] 黄丽娜,苏轼阁,刘莎,等.中文广东话版与普通话版噪声下言语测试材料的开发(英文)[J].中国耳鼻咽喉头颈外科,2005,12(1):55-60.

[7] XI X,CHING T Y,JI F,et al.Development of a corpus of mandarin sentences in babble with homogeneity optimized via psychometric evaluation[J].International Journal of Audiology,2012,51(5):399-404.

[8] XI X,LI J N,YUEN K C P,et al.List equivalency and critical differences of a Mandarin Bamford-Kowal-Bench sentence in babble noise test for adults and pre-school children with normal hearing[J].Journal of Speech Language Hearing Research,2023,66(12):5061-5070.

[9] HU H,XI X,WONG L L N,et al.Construction and evaluation of the Mandarin Chinese matrix (CMNmatrix) sentence test for the assessment of speech recognition in noise[J].International Journal of Audiology,2018,57(11):838-850.

[10] HOLDER J T,LEVIN L M,GIFFORD R H.Speech recognition in noise for adults with normal hearing:age-normative performance for AzBio,BKB-SIN,and QuickSIN[J].Otology& Neurotology,2018,39(10):e972-e978.

[11] WILSON R H,MCARDLE R A,SMITH S L.An evaluation of the BKB-SIN,HINT,QuickSIN,and WIN materials on listeners with normal hearing and listeners with hearing loss[J].Journal of Speech,Language,and Hearing Research,2007,50(4):844-56.

[12] 亓贝尔,刘博,张宁,等.人工耳蜗植入者噪声环境下普通话言语测听测试方案的优化研究[J].听力学及言语疾病杂志,2011,19(4):306-310.

[13] 刘莎,韩德民,张宁,等.普通话语句理解能力分割评分法的比较研究[J].中华耳鼻咽喉头颈外科杂志,2007,42(4):241-244.

[14] 郗昕,黄高扬,冀飞,等.计算机辅助的中文言语测听平台的建立[J].中国听力语言康复科学杂志,2010,8(4):31-34.

[15] 胥科,郑芸,孟照莉.噪声下言语测听的影响因素[J].听力学及言语疾病杂志,2020,28(5):607-611.

[16] KILLION M C,NIQUETTE P A,GUDMUNDSEN G I,et al.Development of a quick speech-in-noise test for measuring signal-to-noise ratio loss in normal-hearing and hearing-impaired listeners[J].Journal of the Acoustical Society of America,2004,116(4 Pt 1):2395-2405.

[17] 任寸寸,刘莎.噪声下言语识别能力评估[J].听力学及言语疾病杂志,2016,24 (3):291-296.

[18] THEUNISSEN M,SWANEPOEL D W,HANEKOM J.Sentence recognition in noise:variables in compilation and interpretation of tests[J].International Journal of Audiology,2009,48(11):743-757.

[19] JANSEN S,LUTS H,WAGENER K C,et al.Comparison of three types of french speech-in-noise tests:a multi-center study[J].International Journal of Audiology,2012,51(3):164-173.

[20] ISO 8253-3:2022 Acoustics-audiometric test methods-Part 3:speech audiometry[S].Geneva:the International Organization for Standardization,2022.

[21] 全国声学标准化技术委员会(SAC/TC 17).声学测听方法第3部分:言语测听:GB/T 16296.3-2017[S].中国标准出版社,2017.